Will Contests and Disputes Lawyers in Texas to Protect Your Rights
What Does Will Contests Mean in Texas?
A will contest is a legal challenge to the validity of a will, which is filed in a probate court. This legal action is an attempt by an ‘interested person,’ such as a beneficiary or heir, to have the probate court declare the will invalid. The goal of a will contest is to prevent it from being probated as written and to alter how the estate is distributed.
Common grounds for a will contest are undue influence, lack of testamentary capacity, fraud/forgery, and improper execution. A will contest is handled in probate court, which determines if the will is valid and how assets should be distributed.
Winning a will contest in Texas is possible, but challenging. Always work with an experienced probate litigation lawyer for the best chance of a successful lawsuit. Texas Estates Code oversees will contests, and high legal skill is essential for a successful outcome.
The Role of a Will Contest Attorney
A will contest attorney plays a vital role in representing those who wish to challenge the validity of a will, or defend a will against challenges in court. A will contest attorney is adept at probate litigation and understands how to navigate the many procedural, legal, and evidentiary aspects of these cases.
An experienced probate process litigation attorney has the following responsibilities:
- Assesses your case: Your attorney reviews the will, your relationship to the estate, and possible grounds for contesting: lack of testamentary capacity, improper execution, undue influence, fraud, and revocation.
- Determines standing: Ensures that you are an ‘interested person,’ such as an heir, beneficiary, or someone named in a prior will. You must have legal standing to contest a will in Texas.
- Explains potential risks: Your probate lawyer will advise on the odds of success, possible costs, and risks. You could, for example, trigger a no-contest clause if you don’t win the case. This outcome could lead to disinheritance if the challenge fails without probable cause and good faith.
Many will contest lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, so the client only pays if the case is successful. Your attorney’s goal is to ensure that the deceased party’s true intentions are honored and that your rights are protected.
Common Grounds for Contesting a Will in Texas
A will contest means challenging the validity in probate court, usually by an ‘interested person, including heirs, beneficiaries, or someone named in a prior will. You must prove that the will is invalid, and the most common grounds are:
Lack of Testamentary Capacity
A common ground contesting a will is that the testator (the person who made the will) lacked the mental capacity to create a valid will at the time of signing. Texas law states that the testator must understand the nature of the will, the extent of their property, the natural objects of their bounty, and how the will distributes their assets.
For a successful will contest, you must show that the deceased person was not mentally capable, possibly due to dementia, Alzheimer’s, or serious mental illness. Possible evidence includes witness testimony, medical records, and expert opinions from medical professionals.
Undue Influence
Undue influence occurs when someone coerces or manipulates the testator, overpowering their free will and resulting in a will that reflects the influencer’s desires rather than the testator’s true intentions. This requires clear and convincing evidence that influence was exerted, it altered the testator’s will, and it caused a distribution different from the one intended.
Evidence might include testimony about the influencer’s control (e.g., isolating the testator), financial records showing suspicious transactions, or unnatural provisions in the will, such as disinheriting close family for an unrelated party. For example, suppose the deceased was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease, and their caregiver isolated them. The caregiver was named as the sole beneficiary of the will before the person’s death. This might be an undue influence claim.
Improper Execution
A will can be contested if it fails to meet Texas’s legal requirements for execution. A formal will must be in writing, signed by the testator (or someone at their direction), and witnessed by at least two credible witnesses over 14 who sign in the testator’s presence. Holographic (handwritten) wills must be entirely in the testator’s handwriting and signed.
Fraud or Forgery
Contesting a will on the grounds of fraud or forgery involves proving the will was created or altered through deceptive means, such as forging the testator’s signature or misleading them about the document’s contents. Evidence may be handwriting analysis showing a forged signature, testimony that the deceased was tricked into signing a document they believed was something else, or discrepancies in the will’s creation process.
Mistake or Revocation
A will could be contested due to a mistake or revocation. For a mistake, evidence like attorney notes or witness testimony must show that the testator misunderstood the will’s effect. For example, suppose you discover a new will after the older one has been probated. You may contend in a will contest that the old will was revoked.
Contesting a Texas will is a challenging process that requires substantial evidence, as well as legal expertise and experience. Your will contest attorney will evaluate your grounds to build the most robust legal claim.
Call us today
At Texas Tax & Estate Law, we are skilled Texas estate planning lawyers who will guide you through the estate planning process. We’ll help you create a will and estate plan, ensuring that your wishes are followed after you pass away.
The Texas Will Contest Process
Follow these steps to contest a will in Texas:
Filing the Will Contest Petition
The process begins when an interested person files a formal petition in the probate court where the estate is being administered, typically the county where the testator resided at the time of death. The petition must be filed within two years of the will’s admission to probate, with rare exceptions for fraud, minors, or incapacity.
The petitioner must specify the grounds for the contest, such as lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, improper execution, fraud, mistake, or revocation, and provide supporting facts. The petitioner must notify all interested parties, such as beneficiaries or the executor.
Discovery and Evidence Gathering
After filing, the discovery phase enables both sides to gather evidence to support their respective positions. The contestant bears the burden of proving the will’s invalidity, typically by a preponderance of the evidence (or clear and convincing evidence for undue influence claims.
This involves gathering medical records to demonstrate incapacity, deposing witnesses to show undue influence, or obtaining documents to prove forgery. Discovery tools include subpoenas, interrogatories, and requests for production. Expert witnesses, such as medical professionals or handwriting analysts, may be engaged to strengthen the case.
Pre-Trial Motions and Mediation
Before the trial starts, the court may address preliminary issues through hearings, such as motions to dismiss for lack of standing or insufficient evidence. Many will contests are resolved during this phase through mediation or settlement negotiations to avoid the expense and uncertainty of a trial. Mediation involves a neutral mediator facilitating discussions to reach a compromise, such as the redistribution of assets.
Your probate attorney plays a critical role in negotiating favorable terms and assessing risks, especially if the will includes a no-contest clause, which could disinherit the contestant if the challenge fails without good faith and probable cause.
Trial and Court Ruling
If the contest advances to trial, both parties present their evidence and arguments before a probate judge. The contestant must overcome the presumption that a properly executed will is valid by presenting evidence such as medical records, witness testimony, or expert opinions. For example, a geriatric psychologist might testify to support a claim of lack of capacity, or family members might describe coercion to support an undue influence claim.
Post-Trial Outcomes and Appeals
If you win the will contest, the will (or its contested parts) is invalidated, and the estate is distributed according to a prior will or Texas intestacy laws, which prioritize spouses, children, or other heirs. If you lose, the will is upheld, and they may face significant consequences, including unrecoverable legal costs, and potential disinheritance under a no-contest clause if the challenge lacked good faith or probable cause.
The Texas will contest process is complicated and expensive. Success rates are approximately 10–20% because of the high evidentiary burden and presumption of validity. An experienced will contest attorney will navigate the process effectively and potentially reduce family disputes.
Gathering Evidence and Protecting Your Rights
Successfully contesting a will in Texas requires gathering robust evidence to support the legal grounds for the challenge and taking proactive steps to protect your rights as an interested party.
The foundation of your successful will contest in Texas is collecting compelling evidence to support the chosen legal grounds. As the contestant, you bear the burden of proving the will’s invalidity by a preponderance of the evidence.
Lack of Testamentary Capacity
For lack of testamentary capacity, critical evidence may include medical records documenting the testator’s mental state, testimony from family, friends, or caregivers about confusion or memory loss at the time of signing, and expert opinions from psychologists or doctors.
Undue Influence
Evidence of undue influence may include financial records showing suspicious transfers, testimony about the influencer’s control or isolation of the testator, or unusual will provisions.
Improper Execution
Improper execution requires proof of procedural defects, such as missing signatures or unqualified witnesses, which is often demonstrated through the will itself or witness statements.
Fraud or Forgery
Important evidence may be handwriting analysis or testimony about deception. Your will contest lawyer may assist in finding evidence of fraud or forgery through a thorough legal investigation.
Mistake or Revocation
Mistake or revocation claims require evidence such as prior wills, written revocations, or statements that demonstrate the testator’s intent.
A successful contest depends on timely legal action, as the statute of limitations in Texas is typically two years.
Why Hire a Will Contest Lawyer in Texas
Hiring a will contest lawyer in Texas is vital if you wish to challenge or defend a will in court. The will challenge process is legally complex, emotionally charged, and often costly. Vital reasons to retain an experienced probate litigation attorney are:
Understands Probate Law and Procedure
A will contest lawyer brings vast knowledge of Texas probate law, including the Texas Estates Code and relevant case law for undue influence claims. They understand the legal requirements for a valid will and the evidentiary burdens needed to win a will contest in court. A will contest attorney ensures your challenge is filed correctly in the appropriate probate court and meets all procedural deadlines, avoiding dismissal due to technical errors.
Engages in Risk Assessment and Case Evaluation
Your Texas will contest attorney evaluates the strength of your case. They will analyze the evidence and pinpoint the most likely grounds for successfully contesting or defending the will. Your attorney will assess if you have legal standing as an ‘interested person,’ and advise on the risks if you lose the case. Your estate planning lawyer will also weigh the possible benefits of the will contest vs the costs.
For instance, We may recommend settling a weak will contest case to avoid expensive litigation.
Gathers Evidence and Presents It Skillfully
Gathering strong evidence is critical to overcoming the presumption that a properly executed will is valid. A will contest lawyer uses discovery tools, such as subpoenas, depositions, and document requests, to collect evidence like medical records for incapacity claims, financial records for undue influence, or handwriting analysis for forgery.
Your attorney will engage experts, such as geriatric psychologists or forensic analysts, to provide credible testimony, and they will interview witnesses (to build a compelling case.
Negotiate and Mediate
Most will contests in Texas are resolved in mediation or settlement. After all, trials are uncertain and costly, sometimes exceeding $50,000. Your will contest lawyer is skilled in negotiating favorable terms, such as redistributing assets, during mediation. For example, if you contest a will that disinherits you, your attorney may negotiate a portion of the estate so both sides can avoid a trial.
Speak to our experienced attorney, to review your will contest issue. He will discuss the best legal options to resolve your situation. Retaining a skilled lawyer will save you time, lower stress, and avoid expensive legal errors.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a “no-contest clause” prevent someone from disputing a will in Texas?
A no-contest clause in your Texas will does not always stop family members from disputing the will. However, the clause may discourage challenges by issuing penalties, such as disinheriting the challenger if they lose the dispute. The courts usually enforce no-contest clauses, except if the will is challenged in good faith and with probable cause.
What is the difference between contesting a will and disputing probate administration?
Contesting a will in Texas means challenging the validity of the will itself, questioning whether it accurately reflects the deceased’s intentions or meets legal requirements. On the other hand, disputing probate administration involves challenging how the estate is being managed or distributed after the will is admitted to probate (or in intestacy if there’s no will).
What evidence is needed to prove undue influence in a Texas will contest?
Proving undue influence in a will contest means showing that the person who wrote the will was manipulated or coerced into writing it in a way that didn’t reflect their wishes. However, Texas courts require strong evidence; undue influence is difficult to prove. An experienced attorney can help you gather robust evidence.
Can a will be challenged for lack of mental capacity of the testator?
Yes, a will can be challenged in Texas for lack of mental capacity of the testator (the person who made the will). This is a common ground for contesting a will’s validity, as Texas law requires the testator to have mental capacity at the time the will was executed.
How much does it cost to contest a will in Texas?
The cost of contesting a will in Texas varies widely depending on the complexity of the case, the attorney’s fees, the duration of the legal process, and other factors. For example, many probate attorneys charge by the hour, typically ranging from $200 to $500. Complex cases requiring more evidence may increase the cost.
How long do you have to dispute a will in Texas?
In Texas, the time limit to contest a will is usually two years from the date the will is admitted to probate. But there are exceptions, such as when the person contesting the will is a minor or incapacitated party.
What percentage of contested wills are successful?
According to the American Bar Association, approximately 0.5–3% of wills in the U.S. are contested, and of those, about 34% are successful in fully or partially overturning the will. Success rates in Texas are often cited as lower than the national average, potentially around 10–20%, depending on the strength of the case.
What kind of will cannot be contested?
In Texas, no will is completely immune from being contested, as any will can be challenged by an interested person. However, certain types of wills make a successful contest difficult, such as a properly executed will, or a will created with an attorney’s assistance.
What happens if you lose contesting a will?
If you lose a will contest in Texas, several consequences may follow, depending on the circumstances of the case, the terms of the will, and Texas law. If the court determines that the will is valid, the estate will be distributed according to the will’s terms. If the will has a no-contest clause, you may forfeit your inheritance or benefits.
On what grounds can a will be contested in Texas?
In Texas, a will can be contested by an “interested person,’ such as heirs, beneficiaries, or those named in a prior will. You must prove strong enough evidence to prove the will is not valid.
Speak to Us Today
You worked hard for your money and property over many years. Secure your legacy today! Consult Texas Tax & Estate Law to craft a valid will and estate plan, navigate community property laws, and streamline probate. Protect your family’s future and contact us today!
